Sarasota, Florida, is not just known for its beautiful beaches and thriving arts scene, but also for its burgeoning culinary landscape. From waterfront dining to hidden gems in the heart of the city, Sarasota offers an impressive array of restaurants catering to foodies of all tastes. Whether you're a fan of seafood, Italian, farm-to-table, or international cuisine, this charming city on the Gulf Coast has something to satisfy every palate.

In this article, we’ll explore some of the top restaurants in Sarasota, where both locals and visitors flock to for unforgettable dining experiences.

1. Indigenous

Cuisine: Farm-to-table
Location: 239 S. Links Ave., Sarasota, FL 34236

Located in Sarasota’s historic Towles Court district, Indigenous is a pioneer in Sarasota’s sustainable dining scene. Head chef and owner Steve Phelps is committed to using local, seasonal ingredients, and his creative menu reflects this dedication. The menu changes frequently based on availability, with popular dishes including the Smoked Fish Dip, Wild Boar Ragout, and Seared Gulf Grouper. The restaurant's cozy, rustic-chic ambiance paired with top-notch service makes Indigenous a must-visit for anyone who appreciates thoughtfully crafted food.

2. Owen's Fish Camp

Cuisine: Southern Seafood
Location: 516 Burns Ln., Sarasota, FL 34236

For a true taste of Southern hospitality, look no further than Owen’s Fish Camp. Nestled in the heart of the Burns Court district, this casual seafood joint combines the best of old Florida charm with a laid-back, family-friendly atmosphere. Known for its fresh catches, such as the Blackened Redfish and Shrimp and Grits, Owen's Fish Camp is a seafood lover’s dream. Be sure to try their famous Fried Green Tomatoes, and if there’s a wait, enjoy a drink in the backyard garden with live music.

3. Selva Grill

Cuisine: Latin Fusion
Location: 1345 Main St., Sarasota, FL 34236

For those in search of bold flavors and modern Latin cuisine, Selva Grill stands out as a hotspot in downtown Sarasota. Known for its vibrant and energetic vibe, Selva Grill offers Peruvian-inspired dishes with a contemporary twist. Their Selva Ceviche is a local favorite, blending citrus-cured seafood with aji amarillo and other Peruvian spices. The fusion of flavors extends to entrees like the Skirt Steak with chimichurri and Lobster Risotto. It’s perfect for a lively night out or a romantic dinner with Latin flair.

4. Shore

Cuisine: Coastal American
Location: 465 John Ringling Blvd., Sarasota, FL 34236

Shore combines sleek, modern design with a relaxed, beachy atmosphere, offering the perfect coastal dining experience. Located near St. Armands Circle, Shore’s menu features fresh seafood and locally sourced ingredients, from the Tuna Poke Bowl to the Pan-Seared Diver Scallops. The outdoor rooftop seating provides the perfect spot for enjoying Sarasota’s sunsets with a cocktail in hand. It’s a trendy yet approachable spot for both lunch and dinner, and the fresh, clean flavors reflect Sarasota’s laid-back coastal vibe.

5. The Rosemary & Thyme

Cuisine: Mediterranean/Continental
Location: 511 N. Orange Ave., Sarasota, FL 34236

Located in the charming Rosemary District, The Rosemary & Thyme offers a combination of Mediterranean-inspired dishes and classic American cuisine. This elegant yet approachable restaurant is known for its warm atmosphere, perfect for a leisurely breakfast, brunch, or dinner. Popular dishes include the Steak Frites, Seafood Paella, and their exceptional Eggs Benedict for brunch lovers. The cozy outdoor seating area is ideal for dining al fresco, adding to the restaurant’s charm.

6. The Bijou Café

Cuisine: French-inspired American
Location: 1287 1st St., Sarasota, FL 34236

For a taste of fine dining with a European touch, The Bijou Café is an iconic Sarasota institution. Since 1986, this intimate, French-inspired bistro has served locals and visitors with elegant dishes such as Duck à l'Orange and Bouillabaisse. Situated near the Sarasota Opera House, it’s a popular choice for pre- or post-show dining. The Bijou Café exudes old-world charm, with white tablecloth service and an extensive wine list, perfect for those seeking a more refined dining experience.

7. Antoine's Restaurant

Cuisine: Belgian/French
Location: 1100 N. Tuttle Ave., Sarasota, FL 34237

Antoine’s Restaurant brings a taste of Belgium to Sarasota, offering an array of European-inspired dishes with a focus on seafood and French cuisine. Mussels are a house specialty, served in various styles such as Marinière and Provencal, and their signature Belgian Waffles are not to be missed. The intimate and charming dining room makes this a great spot for a romantic night out. It’s a hidden gem off the beaten path, perfect for those seeking a cozy and sophisticated dining experience.

8. Mofongo King

Cuisine: Puerto Rican
Location: 935 N Beneva Rd., Sarasota, FL 34232

For a unique taste of the Caribbean, Mofongo King offers authentic Puerto Rican cuisine in Sarasota. Known for their namesake dish, Mofongo, a savory mash of plantains served with garlic, pork cracklings, and your choice of protein, this spot delivers hearty and flavorful meals that transport you to the islands. Other favorites include Pernil (slow-roasted pork) and Empanadas. This casual spot is great for lunch or dinner, offering a satisfying culinary adventure for those seeking bold, tropical flavors.

9. The Capital Grille

Cuisine: Upscale Steakhouse
Location: 180 University Town Center Dr., Sarasota, FL 34243

For those craving a luxurious steakhouse experience, The Capital Grille at the Mall at University Town Center delivers a top-tier dining experience. Known for its expertly aged steaks and fresh seafood, The Capital Grille offers classics like Dry-Aged Porterhouse, Lobster Mac & Cheese, and their signature Bone-In Ribeye. The elegant atmosphere, complete with leather booths and dim lighting, makes this an ideal spot for special occasions or business dinners.

Final Thoughts

From casual beachfront shacks to high-end fine dining, Sarasota’s culinary landscape offers something for everyone. Whether you’re in the mood for fresh seafood, international flavors, or farm-to-table delicacies, these top restaurants will leave you with a taste of Sarasota’s diverse and thriving food scene. No matter where you dine, the city’s love of fresh, local ingredients shines through every dish.

Next time you’re in town, be sure to explore these culinary gems and enjoy all that Sarasota’s vibrant restaurant scene has to offer.

Happy dining, and we’ll see you next week on Bakehouse Weekly!